After yesterday’s Supreme Court Decision
against Aereo, will traditional TV be disrupted?
The First Phase of Disruption Already Started
There has been a major shift away from appointment TV to on-demand viewing, beginning with the DVR, followed by Netflix, and now partially fulfilled by hundreds of OTT on-demand apps, from HBOGO to Crunchyroll. The cable networks, of course, only make their programming available OTT if you authenticate with your cable log-in, preserving MVPD economics. So the only part of the TV ecosystem feeling pressure from this trend is commercial advertising, since, with a few exceptions, the majority of on-demand viewing is commercial free. But this shift to on-demand insures that our kids fully expect all video programming to be portable and on-demand.
Will there be a cheaper cable bundle?
With the end of Aereo, it is unlikely we will see bundled economics of cable TV programming disrupted by a tech company outsider. The only way to offer traditional TV programming over the internet will be to license it from its creators or distributors. Those content owners set rates in such a way as to preserve traditional cable bundle economics. Sure, Apple, Google or Amazon could become an MVPD, but they would be unlikely to offer a cheaper or smaller bundle.
There is real pressure on the bundle, however. Remember, cable TV is really a bundle of bundles. If an MVPD wants ESPN, they must also license and pay for ESPN2, ESPN3, ESPNNews, etc. These mini bundles force MVPDs to pay for more channels than they may otherwise want and in turn must charge consumers more. But they have little choice. Even if you wanted to assemble a smaller, less-expensive bundle of programming, it is made nearly impossible by the imposition of these mini-bundles. And the costs of these mini bundles have been rising, which has led Comcast to buy NBC, Comcast to buy Time-Warner Cable, and now AT&T to buy DirecTV, all as attempts to create leverage against rising mini-bundle costs. This upward price pressure is creating a real problem, since the number of cable subs is now falling in this country. Rising rates, falling subs.
It is unlikely tech companies will be able to meaningfully change these core economics. For this reason, I believe the core disruptive force acting on traditional TV is coming from outside of the TV ecosystem. It is coming in the form of alternate programming being consumed largely by the youngest demographics. I’m talking about YouTube, Twitch.TV and many smaller video companies stealing kids’ time away from the tube.
The Second Phase
YouTube, for many years, was scoffed at by the traditional TV content owners as lacking in quality. But my eleven year old today watches 90% of his video programming on YouTube. CaptainSparkles and Crazy Russian Hacker are true celebrities to him, as big as Kevin Spacey is to me. With more than 6 billion hours of video watched each month, YouTube today reaches more people than any cable network and, even among adults 18-34, they are bigger than any cable network. Their growth rate continues unabated and in short order, YouTube may one day be bigger than all of traditional TV. By buying Twitch, they cement themselves as the overwhelming largest platform for video game content, one of the two most popular content types among kids. And newer entrants like Livestream and YouNow are building engaged audiences with long tail programming.
This view that TV’s competition comes from the bottom is not a new one. (Hunter Walk and I discussed this in this post.) What is new is the widespread shift to mobile devices. As smartphones hit scale, we carry with us both a video creation and consumption device at all times. The real-time web collides with the mobile video web and a new genre of video programming emerges, somewhere between broadcast and messaging. These new personal video formats will steal even more video viewership away from TV, particularly among youth. So if younger kids grow up consuming video away from TV, and TV’s response is continued rising prices of bigger channel bundles, something has to break.